ASIC report shows greed on an industrial scale
Calls to ban harmful lead generation: super should fund retirement, not a sales machine
A damning new ASIC report has exposed how Australians’ retirement savings are being used to fuel a hopelessly conflicted sales model involving the use of marketing companies to sell financial advice. Super Consumers Australia is calling on the Government to entirely ban superannuation lead generation and warning people to just hang up on cold calls.
ASIC’s review of 15 financial advice licensees found that between January 2025 and June 2026:
- 7,639 people were recruited to switch their super through lead generation services.
- $678 million was invested following referrals, with more than 90% coming from super.
- $9.8 million was deducted in upfront advice fees, with consumers agreeing to another $4.5 million in annual ongoing fees.
- Some lead generators were paid up to 100% of the upfront advice fees charged to consumers.
Super Consumers Australia CEO Xavier O’Halloran said the findings exposed the greed driving high-risk super switching schemes.
“Good advisers don’t need to cold call people to get clients. This isn’t about helping Australians get better retirement outcomes. It’s about dodgy operators finding ways to get their hands on your super and charge you as much as possible,” Mr O’Halloran said.
“These businesses are turning people’s retirement savings into a cash cow. The more people they convince to switch, the more money they make, regardless of whether the advice is actually any good.”
ASIC also found unqualified salespeople performing important parts of the financial advice process, misleading consumers about investment performance and financial advice businesses failing to properly supervise their operations.
“The collapse of Shield and First Guardian has already put more than a billion dollars of people’s retirement savings at risk. This report shows the sales machinery behind that disaster is still going strong,” Mr O’Halloran said.
Licensing is not enough
Super Consumers Australia said the review shows that relying on advice licensees to regulate the behaviour of lead generators is not working. The Government needs to rethink its proposed reforms to restrict unlicensed lead generation in light of these new findings.
“Giving these businesses a licence won’t change the financial incentives driving this behaviour. The Government needs to ban lead generation for super switching and financial advice. People should be getting financial advice based on what’s best for them, not what earns a salesperson a payday.”
Super Consumers Australia is also calling for social media platforms to take responsibility for the harmful advertisements that feed these schemes.
“Social media companies verify advertisers and require transparency for political advertising. They should be required to check who’s advertising superannuation services, scrutinise the claims being made and quickly remove harmful ads.
“These platforms are making millions from ads that can lead people to lose their life savings. They shouldn’t be allowed to just collect the advertising revenue and wash their hands of the consequences.”
Even the experts can get caught out
Mr O’Halloran recently tested one of these schemes by signing up for a free super health check advertised on Instagram. He was ultimately offered financial advice costing $11,000 upfront and $3,800 every year.
“I work in superannuation and I knew what to look out for, but the sales pitch was incredibly convincing. They were professional, friendly and knew exactly how to make me question my existing super fund,” Mr O’Halloran said.
Super Consumers Australia is urging Australians to be wary of social media advertisements offering free super health checks, comparisons or help finding lost super.
“Don’t make decisions about your retirement savings because someone contacts you after you’ve clicked on an ad. Hang up on cold calls. You don’t have to be polite. Get independent information before agreeing to anything,” Mr O’Halloran said.
For more information about how lead generation works or how to choose a good financial adviser, head to Moneysmart.gov.au.
People invested in Shield or First Guardian Master Funds through switching schemes can visit takeyoursuperback.com for free, independent information about getting help.